— Domani Spero
[twitter-follow screen_name=’Diplopundit’ ]
VIDEO: AP investigation reveals USAID ran an HIV clinic in Cuba as a front to recruit potential activists: http://t.co/RagtIFCNyY
— The Associated Press (@AP) August 4, 2014
Whose brainchild is this, pray tell.
Alan Gross, the 65-year-old American citizen mentioned in this article has been imprisoned in Cuba since 2009. His family has mounted a petition demanding Mr. Gross’ “immediate release” and that “the Cuban and U.S. governments sit down and resolve Alan’s case.”
This morning, USAID released a statement about what it calls, the AP’s “sensational claims,”excerpt below:
Congress funds democracy programming in Cuba to empower Cubans to access more information and strengthen civil society. USAID makes information about its Cuba programs available publicly at foreignassistance.gov. This work is not secret, it is not covert, nor is it undercover. Instead, it is important to our mission to support universal values, end extreme poverty and promote resilient, democratic societies. Chief among those universal values are the right to speak freely, assemble and associate without fear, and freely elect political leaders. Sadly, the Cuban people and many others in the global community continue to be denied these basic rights.
One paragraph in the article captures the purpose of these and many civil society programs, which is to empower citizens to “tackle a community or social problem, win a ‘small victory’ and ultimately realize that they could be the masters of their own destiny.” But the story then goes on to make sensational claims against aid workers for supporting civil society programs and striving to give voice to these democratic aspirations. This is wrong.
USAID remains committed to balancing the realities of working in closed societies–particularly in places where we do not have a USAID mission and governments are hostile to U.S. assistance–with our commitment to transparency, and we continuously balance our commitment to transparency with the need for discretion in repressive environments. In the end, USAID’s goal is to continue to support democracy, governance and human rights activities in multiple settings, while providing the maximum transparency possible given the specific circumstances.
A couple of items from that USAID statement: 1) “the Cuban people and many others in the global community,” does that mean this happened in Cuba and elsewhere?; 2) “with our commitment to transparency” — USAID’s Cuba programs data available publicly at foreignassistance.gov only covers FY2013 and 2014 and not the years covered by the AP report. USAID also would not tell the AP how much the Costa Rica-based program cost.
These young “aid workers” from Venezuela, Costa Rica and Peru sent to Cuba could have been arrested and jailed for 10 years for the work they did for USAID, and the agency would have been able to claim that these are not USG employees. The US has not been able to effect the release of USAID contractor Alan Gross, would it be any more successful intervening for the release of foreign nationals who are not? Also, the notion that you can run democracy promotion operations like this in certain parts of the world and that it will not have a dangerous blowback against USAID employees advancing development work in other parts of the world, is frankly, lunacy.
Does USAID have a scenario planned for what happens after a ‘Cuban Spring’unfolds in Cuba? Is it publicly available at fomentingchange.gov?
Just a reminder, the nominee for USAID OIG, in case you’re wondering has been waiting for Senate confirmation since July 2013 (see Officially In: Michael G. Carroll – From Deputy IG to USAID/OIG).
* * *
- 5 findings about USAID travelers’ program in Cuba (miamiherald.com)
- American Imprisoned in Cuba Begins Hunger Strike (abcnews.go.com)
- Promoting democracy in countries where USAID isn’t welcome is a delicate balancing act (miamiherald.com)
- Maryland Man Imprisoned In Cuba Since 2009 Begins Hunger Strike (baltimore.cbslocal.com)
- Alan Gross hunger strike worries Cuba (miamiherald.com)
- U.S. Sent Latin Youths To Cuba To Push For Change (miami.cbslocal.com)
- US Endangers Public Health Efforts with Spying, Again (emptywheel.net)