— Domani Spero
The State Department’s Assistant Secretary of State for European Affairs, Victoria Nuland was caught on tape with Geoffrey Pyatt, the U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine working the diplomatic sausage over the Ukraine crisis. The private conversation was recorded and uploaded to YouTube by an anonymous user/s who made an effort to include a photo collage of the individuals referred to in the conversation. The leaked recording is available here and has been viewed 485,122.
The State Department spokeswoman was asked if this call is “an authentic recording of an authentic conversation between Assistant Secretary Nuland and Ambassador Pyatt?” As can be expected, Ms. Psaki replied:
“Well, I’m not going to confirm or outline details. I understand there are a lot of reports out there and there’s a recording out there, but I’m not going to confirm private diplomatic conversations.”
Hilarious exchange followed:
QUESTION: As related to Assistant Secretary Nuland’s comments about the European Union, do – are the United States and the EU on the same page on what to deal – how to deal with the situation in Ukraine and how best to resolve the crisis?
MS. PSAKI: Well, let me first say, obviously, we work incredibly closely with the EU and with representatives of the EU, and Assistant Secretary Nuland certainly does as it relates to Ukraine. And she’s been in close contact with EU High Representative Ashton. Also, let me convey that she has been in contact with her EU counterparts, and of course, has apologized. But —
QUESTION: What did she apologize for?
MS. PSAKI: For these reported comments, of course.
QUESTION: So you’re not confirming that the comments are accurate? She’s —
MS. PSAKI: I’m just not going to speak to a private diplomatic conversation, Arshad, but I’m obviously speaking to the content of the reports.
Ukraine’s Security Service has reportedly declined to comment on a leaked recording of this telephone conversation.
The Guardian says that Germany condemns the comments made by Assistant Secretary Nuland:
The German spokeswoman Christiane Wirtz said Merkel appreciated the work of Catherine Ashton, the EU’s foreign policy chief, who had tried to mediate between the Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanukovych, and protesters who have taken to the streets. “The chancellor finds these remarks totally unacceptable and wants to emphasise that Mrs Ashton is doing an outstanding job,” Wirtz said.
Meanwhile, Polish Minister of Foreign Affairs Radosław Sikorski tweeted his support:
In Kiev, Assistant Secretary Nuland also refused to comment “on a private diplomatic conversation” except to say “It was pretty impressive tradecraft. [The] audio quality was very good.” And so here we are:
And as to those who are shocked, just shocked, by the U.S. attempt to manipulate Ukraine’s opposition, this is exactly what diplomats at higher levels try to do: All the foreign ambassadors in Washington worth their pensions have salty, Machiavellian conversations with their superiors and colleagues about how to shape votes of the U.S. Congress. If you’re an American, be glad that pros such as Nuland are on the job, and hope that your other diplomats aren’t sitting around munching cucumber sandwiches in between demarches.
That said, here is one scandal that this intercepted call does point to, however: Were Nuland and Pyatt speaking, as they should have been, on the kind of encrypted phone designed for such discussions? If not, that’s a major diplo-no-no. If they were, and some foreign power still managed to crack the code, then Uncle Sam needs to invest in some new phones ASAP.
Continue reading Sometimes Diplomacy Needs the F-Word.
This is a congressional hearing just waiting to happen. Where did you learn such language? Who did what, where, when with these phones and how come you did not know that you were bugged? Congress is always curious about those things.
Now, please do us a favor and stop sending us hate mail for Ms. Nuland.
* * *
- Top U.S. diplomat launches f-bomb on EU in leaked recorded conversation (security.blogs.cnn.com)
- Russian official denies role in Nuland call leak (cnsnews.com)
- US Diplomat’s Remark on European Union ‘Unacceptable,’ Merkel Says – New York Times (nytimes.com)
- Intercepted F-Bomb Phone Call Shows U.S. Role in Ukraine (bloomberg.com)
- Leaked Call Controversy Highlights Global Tension Over Ukraine (thewire.com)
- U.S. Diplomat’s Leaked Phone Call Gets Poor Reception (npr.org)
- US sees Russian hand in envoy’s bugged call (stripes.com)
- American Diplomat Caught On Tape Saying “Fuck the EU” (gawker.com)
- Diplomat Victoria Nuland caught on tape letting rip while discussing Ukraine crisis (dailymail.co.uk)